This Essay appears to be the first to recognize the presence of rejection sensitivity dysphoria (“RSD”) among law students and to suggest a pedagogical approach for addressing it during peer-review lessons. RSD is not a formal diagnosis but instead describes a common expression of emotional dysregulation surfacing in over seventy percent of individuals with Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (“ADHD”) and occurring frequently in those on the Autism Spectrum, as well as in people with anxiety and depression. Patients of Dr. William Dodson, who was first to coin the term “RSD,” describe an RSD reaction as emotional pain that presents intensely, like a physical injury. They characterize it as excruciating and often accompanied by particularized physical pain, such as pain in the chest. The symptoms of RSD are varied but are notably outsized reactions, including rage, and are often followed by periods of shame, withdrawal, and even suicidal ideation. RSD reactions are triggered by rejection or the perception of it, with one of the most common triggers being criticism or feedback, regardless of how constructively the feedback is offered.
Process-oriented pedagogy, which is heavy on feedback, collaboration, and peer review, is often used in legal writing and other skills courses. Because the feedback-heavy model can be triggering of RSD, a tension arises; thus, incorporating extensive and intentional messaging around both giving and receiving feedback is critical when using process-oriented pedagogy with today’s law students. Peer-review projects, particularly those found within a larger collaborative assignment, provide the ideal opportunity for law faculty to deliver such messaging. The payoff for doing so is well worth the effort. Students develop a keen eye for assessing the writing of others and sharpen their ability to provide actionable feedback. They also begin to observe their own reaction to feedback without judgment, thereby developing stronger self-efficacy and greater resilience as legal writers.