This Article examines the Red Lake Nation’s seizure of a non-Indian pilot’s aircraft after an emergency landing on a Minnesota public highway passing through the Red Lake Reservation. The legal issues combine to create an illuminating conflict, one that questions both the rights of airmen operating in the National Airspace System and Tribes’ sovereign powers.
The Article takes the form of a dialogue, presenting two distinct views on Tribal airspace. Ronnie Gipson offers analysis informed by aviation law. Alexandra Fay presents a perspective based in federal Indian law. While the authors do not come to a singular conclusion, the discord between the two accounts highlights deeper tensions in federal law. In this way, this local incident serves as a vehicle for a broader discussion of Tribal sovereignty and federal preemption.